The Bachelor 2016's Becca Tilley and Amber James vie for Ben

Becca Tilley, 26, and Amber James, 30, added a wrinkle to The Bachelor premiere on Monday when they returned to the show.

The Bachelor season 20 The season of the crazies

112 Becca Dean Photos & High Res Pictures - Getty Images

The Bachelor': Twitter has a field day

Bachelor' Stars Who Returned to the Franchise Again and Again

Becca Tilley virgin – Ok! Here's the Situation – O!HitS

The Bachelor 2016's Jubilee Sharpe tells contestants to back off

Ben Higgins OK! Magazine

Two Bachelor Alumni Are Returning to Compete for Ben Higgins' Love

The Bachelor OK! Magazine